Abortion is legal in Italy — so why are women being refused?
Women’s abortion rights in Italy are the worst they have been since the 1970s as a civil war rages on the issue, campaigners claim.
They say increasing numbers of gynecologists are refusing to carry out terminations, forcing women into unsafe, illegal abortions.
It comes amid a publicity drive from anti-abortion organizations that are attempting to demonize women who terminate, according to Silvana Agatone, president of LAIGA, an association of gynecologists that supports abortion rights.
Anti-abortion groups say they hope the number of conscientious objectors increases and that women’s choice should end when another life is involved.
Why is getting an abortion tougher?
Italy legalized abortion on May 22, 1978 — exactly forty years ago today — allowing women to terminate in the first three months of pregnancy or after if the mother’s life is at risk or there is an abnormal fetus.
But the legislation contained a clause allowing doctors, nurses, anesthetists, and others to declare themselves conscientious objectors and refuse to perform abortions.
Figures compiled by the Italian government show the percentage of gynecologists objecting has jumped from 58.7% in 2005 to 70.9% in 2016.
It’s not just gynecologists who professionally object to carry out terminations, nearly half of anesthetists refuse to get involved, according to official data.
Agatone claims other staff use more subtle means to disrupt abortions, such as nurses who don’t wash the utensils needed to carry out the operation, or hospital porters that refuse to wheel in patients for terminations.
“They don’t use the conscientious objection, they abuse the objection,” Agatone told Euronews.
“The environment around you is very negative because if you provide abortions you are treated like a criminal.
“It’s very difficult to work in an environment that is so against you and makes so many problems for you.”
What are the consequences?
Agatone says the higher number of objectors often means desperate women — either by choice or by necessity — having to go from town-to-town searching for someone who will carry out the operation. If they don’t find someone, they are forced into hidden, illegal and unsafe abortions.
Government figures show around 60% of medical establishments provide abortions; Agatone says all should by law.
Agatone’s claims come amid a publicity drive by anti-abortion organizations such as ProVita Onlus and CitizenGo.
Agatone said the increasing number of conscientious objectors and the prominence of anti-abortion groups means abortion rights for women are at the worst level since terminations were legalized 40 years ago.
“It’s becoming much worse,” she added. “This month I’m seeing stuff I’ve never seen before — there’s a civil war on abortion.”
Why is this happening?
Experts say conscientious objectors are rising because gynecologists who are against abortion find it easier to advance in Italian hospitals.
“The system in the hospitals favor the career of the objectors, while non-objecting doctors are often mobbed and discriminated and have to carry the responsibility alone to ensure that the law is implemented,” said Irene Donadio, spokeswoman for the International Planned Parenthood Federation European Network.
“Some are forced to travel to different hospitals to ensure that women receive care in regions in which there is a huge percentage of hospitals that are not ensuring the service via their permanent staff.
“Of course even this is not enough and many women are forced to move to hospitals in other parts of the country to try to get the care they are entitled to.”
Donadio said the rise of populism has also helped foster the growing influence of anti-abortion groups.
“These groups can enjoy a much bigger political influence now that the League has won the elections and is about to enter the new government,” she added.
“The League is close to Russia and Trump and shares a very oppressive agenda around women’s reproductive autonomy.
“The populist Five-Star Movement is flirting with the far-right wingers and from their programme, it seems they care more about stopping children getting vaccines than women’s right to health or how they are treated in hospitals.”